Recipes » Make Your Own » MYO Heavy Cream Substitute

MYO Heavy Cream Substitute

fb iconpinterest iconpinterest iconlinkedin iconbuffer icon

Heavy cream is often called for in baked goods recipes and it can be rather expensive to have on hand. Here are a couple of different homemade substitutes that work well in place of heavy cream.

MYO Heavy Cream Substitute

You’ll Need:
3/4 cup milk (not low fat)
1/3 cup real butter, melted but not hot enough to boil!

Put the whole milk In a bowl, add the melted butter and whip with a whisk attachment or hand beater on medium for about 2 minutes.

If you plan on making your own Whipping Cream use 1/2 c. butter instead of one-third.

Refrigerate the mixture in a covered container. If using the cream in soups, sauces, or baked goods, it’s ready immediately.

To use it in homemade whipped cream it must be refrigerated for at least 24 hours. Do not use margarine as this is merely oil and does not work.

Did you know regular heavy cream has 100 calories and 11 grams of fat per 2 tablespoons? If you are looking to drastically reduce your calories, substituting an equal amount of half-and-half cream for the heavy cream called for in a recipe generally works quite well.

Or, alternatively, you can give this low-fat heavy cream substitute a try:

Low-Fat Heavy Cream Substitute for Cooking & Baking

8 ounces low fat cottage cheese
3 tablespoons non-fat powdered milk


Combine and in a blender, puree for 3 minutes, use in your favorite recipe calling for heavy cream. This is not meant to replace whipping cream but can be used in baked goods recipes calling for heavy cream.

12 Best Substitutes for Heavy Cream

We shared with you the most flavorful substitute above, which is perfect for baked goods but doesn’t offer the best results for whipped cream to use on desserts such as pie.

The first substitute you could try using would be vanilla yogurt, which has similar properties as regular dairy milk while still being much healthier than its counterpart – plus there’s no need to buy another container when yours will do just fine for a while since they’re both added with probiotics too so don’t forget those little guys either 🙂

Coconut Milk

Pure plain coconut milk is the best option if you’re attempting to make whipped cream without heavy cream. The caveat to this option is that the can needs to be refrigerated for several hours or overnight to get the cream to separate appropriately first.

Also, it’s important not to mistake cream of coconut, which is heavily sweetened, for pure coconut milk.
Nevertheless, this does impart a slight coconut flavor, so take that into consideration when using it in your recipe.

splendid coconut whipped cream
Splendid Coconut Whipped Cream

Half & Half Heavy Cream Substitute

Half and half is excellent as a heavy cream substitute for cooking, but not for baking. Instead, use it in a 1:1 even swap ratio in your favorite soups and sauces.

Half and half heavy cream substitute is not the best option for use in baked goods recipes that rely on the high-fat content to achieve the correct structure.

Soy Milk & Olive Oil

The combination of shelf-stable soy milk and olive oil will create a vegan heavy cream substitute with a rich texture in most recipes calling for heavy cream. Use two parts soy milk with 1 part olive oil; for example, to make one cup of soy heavy cream substitute, use 2/3 cup of soy milk and 1/3 cup of olive oil.
Olive oil does alter the flavor a bit. If you want a vegan whipped cream replacement, puree silken tofu with soymilk.
soy milk heavy cream substitutes

Evaporated Milk

Canned cream (also known as evaporated milk), this shelf-stable product, has twice the fat of whole milk, making it ideal for soups and casseroles. It will provide creaminess as well as a slightly caramelized taste. To achieve a slightly higher fat content, add a tablespoon or two of butter to the recipe as well.

Greek Yogurt

To add body to mashed potatoes and creamy soups and sauces, use full-fat plain Greek yogurt—just off the heat to prevent curdling.
To more closely mimic the texture of heavy cream, thin it with whole milk.

Use Greek yogurt in dessert recipes that need to be shipped, such as cookies or cakes; if you want a fast sweet topping, however, sweeten Greek yogurt with a little bit of confectioners’ sugar.
greek yogurt heavy cream substitutes

Cream Cheese

In a pinch, you can replace heavy cream with either tangy cream cheese or mascarpone.
Either may be used as-is by stirring directly into a hot dish; because they melt into a creamy puddle, replicating the realistic feel and taste of heavy cream. Beat cream cheese with confectioners ‘ sugar instead to make dessert topping (such as cream cheese icing).

Milk & Cornstarch

Here’s how to use milk and cornstarch as a heavy cream substitute.
1 Pour 1 cup of milk into a heavy-bottomed saucepan.
2 Slowly heat the milk, constantly stirring with a whisk. Avoid letting it boil over.
3 In a bowl, mix together 2 tablespoonfuls of cornstarch and 4 tablespoons of cold water. While continuously stirring, pour the cornstarch mixture into the saucepan with the hot milk. Keep stirring for 3 minutes or until the mixture thickens.
4 Allow it to cool before storing it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days.
5 Before using as a heavy cream substitute, you need to beat the mixture to make it smooth.

Sour Cream & Mayonnaise

In place of heavy whipping cream on hand? Just whip equal parts sour cream and mayonnaise! That’s heavy cream equivalent to one cup. This works best in baked goods to achieve good structure and richness.

Low Fat Heavy Cream Substitute

For those who want heavy cream substitutes with fewer calories and fat, here’s how:

1) Reduce heavy cream by 1/3 and blend in 1 cup of nonfat Greek yogurt. (OR)

2) Beat one cup of whipping cream until stiff peaks form, then fold in 3 tablespoons of heavy cream substitute (water + heavy cream powder). Adding heavy cream powder to your heavy cream substitute will help you achieve a similar texture as full-fat heavy cream.

3) You can also use unflavored, unsweetened almond milk instead if the lighter version is preferred. Mix 2 cups of almond milk with 5 teaspoons of cornstarch dissolved in 5 tablespoons cold water first, before heating them up on the stove, stirring constantly. In the end, beat 1 cup of heavy cream until stiff peaks form and fold it in.

Whipping Cream as a Replacement for Heavy Cream

Whipping cream and heavy cream are not the same. The definition of heavy cream is one with no less than 36% milk fat. Whipping cream contains a slightly lower percentage of milk fat, between 30 and 36%.

For those who simply want to swap whipping cream for heavy cream to reduce fat content and/or calories, try mixing 1/4 cup of whipping cream with 3/4 cup of milk. This will help you achieve the same consistency as using heavy whipping cream straight from your fridge without compromising moisture content in your dishes.

© Can Stock Photo Inc. / PhotoEuphoria

View More MYO from Scratch Recipes