Here are various ideas I have gathered and a few that have been submitted by guests like yourself! Be creative when choosing names and adding various contents, you’ll be surprised at what you can come up with!
- African snake
- Ashwinder eggs
- Australian Billywig stings-causes giddiness & levitation
- Baboon’s blood — corn syrup and red foodcoloring
- Baby finger
- Belladonna aka Deadly Nightshade
- Blind worm’s sting
- Bonemeal
- Boomslang skin
- Cockroaches- (rubber cockroaches)
- Crushed snake fangs
- Devils claw
- Doxy eggs – black in color
- Dragon Claws
- Dragon eggs – pale grey
- Dragon scale
- Dragon tongue
- Dried stinging nettles
- The essence of Lost souls (perfect for an incense stick!)
- Eye of newt- (fake pearls separated)
- Fen snake — rubber snake
- Fluxweed
- Galangal Root
- Gall bladder of goat — silly putty
- Gargoyle sweat
- Ginger root
- Glumbumble juice –to induce melancholy
- Graphorn powder – dragon
- Heart
- Hen’s Teeth (use rice)
- Horn of Bicorn
- Horn slugs
- Jellyfish Stingers- use hot glue strands in a bottle with water
- Jobberknoll feathers
- Knot grass
- Lacewing flies
- Leeches – Leeches juice
- Lizard scales
- Mandrake root
- Mermaids Tail
- Monkshood
- Mummy Dust
- Ogre Boogers
- Owlet wing — raid fly tying supplies for feathers
- Peruvian Viper tooth
- Phoenix Feathers
- Pickled Griffin Claws
- Plangentine
- Poisoned Entrails (Straight from Shakespeare)
- Poison Mandrake
- Porcupine Quills
- Powdered moonstone
- Scarab Beetles
- Shrivel fig
- Slug Spew – use dyed cornstarch -mix a small amount of water with yellow dye, add cornstarch
- slurry yellow
- Snake Oil- To enhance Deceptive Elixirs
- Step-Mother
- Toad Venom — cornstarch slurry dyed maroon, or glowy
- Toe of frog
- Tongue of dog (Laffy Taffy shaped by hand to resemble tongue)
- Troll teeth
- Unicorn hair
- Valerian root
- Venomous Tentacula
- Vampire blood
- Wolf tooth
- Wool of bat — cotton wool, dyed black
- Wormwood
Some of these items are from the Harry Potter Series- that is an Excellent place to start if you’re looking for Witchy Potions & Elixirs.




my daughters and i are having a ball with this idea! what is the name of the font you used on your labels – we love it!
The styles used are listed on the Witch Bottle Directions page: Budget101.com – – Witches Apothecary Shop – Witch Bottles | Homemade Halloween Decor
The styles were Blackadder & chiller. 🙂